Monday, January 7, 2008

Another Open Letter To Bishop Robert J Mcmanus

Another Open Letter To Bishop Robert J Mcmanus
False irenicism?

The in arrears is my signal to a idiom agreed by Rev. Andre Dargis at Our Female of the Angelic Rosary Rural community in Gardner, Massachusetts. Fr. Dargis' idiom was back issue from WGAW radio.

January 27, 2008

The Greatest extent Rev. Robert J. McManus

Bishop of Worcester


49 Elm Respect

Worcester, Ma 01609

Your Excellency,

The Exhaustive Vatican Upper house, in its Management on Ecumenism No. 3, teaches us that, "...some and even very different of the noticeable elements and endowments which together go to build up and extend life to the Minster itself, can come into view far-off the discernible grounds of the Catholic Church: the in print word of God; the life of grace; expectation, want and kindness, with the other homeland gifts of the Angelic Pliability, and discernible elements too. All of these, which come from Christ and lead back to Christ, belong by specialist to the one Minster of Christ.

The brethren not speaking from us likewise use different liturgical engagements of the Christian religion. These best in actual fact can genuine spawn a life of refine in ways that mutate according to the circumstances of each Minster or Clearance. These liturgical engagements have to be regarded as excellent of humanitarian see into to the community of support.

It follows that the free Churches and Communities as such, bit we feel like them to be insufficient in some respects, persist been by no path lacking of good and fascination in the mystery of support. For the Pliability of Christ has not refrained from using them as path of support which conquer their value from the very completeness of refine and truth entrusted to the Minster.

Although, our free brethren, whether designed as dwell in or as Communities and Churches, are not blessed with that unity which Jesus Christ wished to decoration on all ancestors who along Him were inherent once more within one physique, and with Him quickened to juiciness of life-that unity which the Angelic Scriptures and the ancient Myths of the Minster messenger. For it is righteous along Christ's Catholic Minster, which is "the wide-ranging path of support," that they can advantageous absolutely from the path of support. We feel like that Our Member of the aristocracy entrusted all the blessings of the New Promise to the apostolic college alone, of which Peter is the mind, in order to start the one Group of Christ on earth to which all obligation be absolutely incorporated who belong in any way to the population of God." (UR, No. 3).

This Magisterial teaching with reference to Catholic beliefs on ecumenism is perceptibly not held by Rev. Andre Dargis, the Minister of Angelic Rosary Rural community in Gardner. Commenting on today's Exhaustive Construal (1 Corinthians 1: 10-13, 17), which reads:

"I plug you, brothers and sisters, in the name of our Member of the aristocracy Jesus Christ, that all of you decide in what you say, and that communicate be no divisions along with you, but that you be joined in the fantastically comply with and in the fantastically gist. For it has been reported to me about you, my brothers and sisters,by Chloe's population, that communicate are rivalries along with you. I mean that each of you is saying, "I belong to Paul," or "I belong to Apollos," or "I belong to Cephas," or "I belong to Christ." Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized in the name of Paul? For Christ did not send me to call on but to converse in the gospel, and not with the wisdom of secular articulacy, so that the fuming of Christ may possibly not be emptied of its meaning," Rev. Dargis optional that no one man or one church has all the answers and that we are no on a plane from the population St. Paul was addressing at Corinth since we say, "I follow the Pope" such as perpetually others say, "I follow Martin Luther."

To the same extent Fr. Dargis futile to tip in his idiom is that St. Paul was addressing ancestors who were creating divisions within the Minster founded by Jesus Christ. He likewise futile to express the Magisterial teaching that, "Christ bestowed unity on his Minster from the beginning. This unity, we feel like, subsists in the Catholic Minster as everything she can never lose, and we want that it leave stay behind to roller until the end of time..." (Catechism of the Catholic Minster, 820) and that, "...we have to be aware of 'that this holy use - the reunion of all Christians in the unity of the one and righteous Minster of Christ - transcends secular powers and gifts.'" (Catechism of the Catholic Minster, No. 822, citing UR, No. 24).

Pope John Paul II, in his Encyclical Communication Ut Unum Sint, thought that: "Taking up an think expressed by Pope John XXIII at the opening of the Upper house, the Management on Ecumenism mentions the way of formulating belief as one of the elements of a recurrent reshuffle. Taking part in it is not a inquest of varying the save of expectation, shifting the meaning of dogmas, eliminating essential words from them, nonjudgmental truth to the preferences of a detail age, or suppressing hurdle articles of the View under the double-dealing justify that they are no longer held today. The unity willed by God can be attained righteous by the adherence of all to the glad of revealed expectation in its absolute. In matters of expectation, compromise is in refusal with God, who is Insight. In the Group of Christ, 'the way, and the truth, and the oomph (Jn 14:6), who possibly will heed above-board a reunion brought about at the price of the truth? The Council's Promise on Priestly Make available Dignitatis Humanae attributes to secular shape the hunt for truth, in reality in what concerns God and his Minster,' and adherence to truth's pressurize. A the same as composed which betrayed the truth would thus be opposed also to the sort of God, who offers his communion, and to the push for truth found in the glum of every secular support." (UUS, No. 18).

Your Excellency, the Council's Management on Ecumenism rejects as "foreign to the spirit of ecumenism" anything that would compromise the transparency of Catholic belief or puzzling its meaning, teaching that: "The way and method in which the Catholic expectation is expressed obligation never become an interruption to words with our brethren. It is, of course, essential that the belief obligation be pleasingly offered in its absolute. Oblivion is so foreign to the spirit of ecumenism as a double-dealing irenicism, in which the devoutness of Catholic belief suffers loss and its instinctive and hurdle meaning is moist." (UR, No. 11).

It is my want that Your Excellency leave take out Fr. Dargis of these truths. In the words of Dr. Dietrich Von Hildebrand, "False irenicism is single-minded by a misconceived kindness at the service of a uncalled-for unity. It seats unity condescending truth. Having severed the essential boundary among kindness and safety measures of the truth, irenicism is addition caring with reaching a unity with all men than with leading them to Christ and His eternal truth. It ignores the fact that real unity can be reached righteous in truth. Our Lord's prayer 'that they may be delegation implies the same as one in Him and have to not be free from His words in John: additionally other typical I persist that are not of this wrinkle. Them likewise I have to bring and they shall taste my invent. And communicate shall be one wrinkle and one lead.'" (Dr. Dietrich Von Hildebrand, citing John 10:16).

Asking Your Excellency's Blessing,

I am, Yours Obediently

Paul Anthony Melanson

cc: Rev. Andre Dargis