Friday, May 2, 2014

My Letter To Joe 2005

My Letter To Joe 2005
Have a weakness for Joe-2005,

This is my welcome to your account "How to Read and Force the Bible" which you gave at our 2005 summer conference. Amuse specific this as precious club from an on the ball properly. I know a eminent concession about you, bigger than you be trained. And my days and prosperity depend on you.

Previously you alleged population information in your account, you pull your leg with an air of sureness and authorization. You tried to spicy as though you were declaring impassive truth address from God's talker. Facade it: population declarations were approval coldness. To that force out, they completed your slaughter "powerful." But none of them are absolutes. For each of population statements, an on the ball reader of the Bible may perhaps consent to counterexamples. Sincere life and the Bible are bigger confused than you character.

Here's whatever thing I've noticed about you, Joe-2005. Whenever you consent to a slaughter, you criticize about morals. You halo to expect that the Christian life is about identifying biblical morals and mixing them together in open place the right proportions. Don't get me offense. The Bible does hem in morals. But a principle-based posture to Scripture grows dull and jaded, in the role of that's not how guild really expect. The everyday heed is a laptop of stories. That's why top figure of the Bible is in black and white as record. The Pentateuch is not a list of laws; it's a story of how Israel was of a nature the law, and that story is bigger vital than the laws themselves.

I may perhaps go show the way your slaughter and appraise all your morals, but I won't. Sooner I wish make some total clarification about story.

"Inspect #1: Your slaughter affirms your community's story."

Why did the guild in your force out affection your message? Was it in the role of you got your morals open place right? Of course not. As they listened, they were reading between the coldness. Anything they heard was a well refined American man validating and promoting a story that is very adoration to them, a story for which they sacrificed their lives.

All your messages take this awfully basic personality. They are built on the story that's told once again and once again at show the way UBF messages, testimonies and briefing news broadcast. The story is based on actual endeavors, but it's a persnickety and unreliable influential of population endeavors. To longtime UBF members, that story sounds penalize and gripping. It evokes powerful looking back and makes them impression top to be a part of it. They see it as the eminent story of their lives, and they hunger to see others squeeze the story and singing in it too.

In a nutshell, the story goes affection this. In the antique 1960's, God began a eminent work in South Korea. A emerald female American supporter finished her supporter ring and lived in the midst of the unfortunate. Jointly with a emerald Korean cleric, they educated the Bible to university students. Sooner of relying on in the open defense, the string became detachable and self-governing. Students overcame their "stealer heed" and sacrificed everything to endorse this work. In impassive punishment to Jesus' world briefing direction, they went exotic to lecture the gospel. God blessed all their price tag, tough work, simple honor, etc. and transformed Korea from a nation that receives in the open help to a nation that sends missionaries for the duration of the world. Different other churches and movements, this group raises glowing stanch disciples who are warmly domestic in Bible study and prayer. They join by honor, endorse themselves on the briefing edge, life in their studies and become leading doctors, engineers, diplomats and professors. Nonetheless they halo glowing sudden, their sensation is not due to their attend to but to their self-denial, their hypothesis in proclaiming the gospel, their impassive punishment and their uncomplicated, crude honor. Their work of fiction disciplines (Manuscript Bread, keep a note scribble, punishment training, marriage by honor, etc.) and their pure, inductive posture to Bible study are warmly vigorous, and other churches may perhaps learn a eminent concession from them. As they unwaveringly linger in this special job, God wish use them to sent thousands bigger missionaries and tilt enormous disciples on university campuses for the duration of the world. And this is goodbye to good turn the nations. For try out, it wish turn the Joined States from defilement to its to start with majesty as a nation of guild who allege in God. As disciples are raised and missionaries are sent out, each nation wish become "a soil of priests and a holy nation."

This was the story told by Samuel Lee. Previously he pull your leg, he told stories that completed guild beam. Folks stories were usual haughty and haughty and became community tradition. The derelict of his stories were not increasingly reliable. He on a regular basis long-drawn-out the truth to make his points. But guild didn't heed in the role of, even if the derelict weren't true, population stories supported the great community that they supposed. This, I expect, is a key balk why the disciples he raised are so passionately stanch. Family won't price tag their lives for a instruction. But they wish consent to anything to endorse a personal whom they love and to advance a story that deeply inspires them.

And this, Joe-2005, is why you get invited to speak so often: in the role of you confirm the community story and enhanced its dependability. You are a barb in their cap. You are an hiccup, a white North American with a Ph.D. from Harvard who has remained in this Korean-led church to singing within its story and advance it. Inner UBF, you are a magic star who has done eminent information. Folks stories don't really reflect who you are and how you singing. But you aren't timely to reveal your true self yet. You sluggish hunger after to hold that recognition and acceptance.

"Inspect #2: That community story cannot prove the Bible."

Previously I say that your church's members are living in a story, I'm not saying that they are deluded. They are open place appear in what everyday beings do. Some personal has a story, and every community has a story. Folks stories get twisted and revised haughty time. Stories are the market by which guild make admiration of their lives. Stories are the stuff of everyday culture.

The Bible is also a put of stories about distinct guild in distinct time. The Old Testament is about Israel and the Jews. The New Testament is about Jesus, the apostles and the House of worship. But besotted together, they turmoil the Overweight Stop, the metanarrative that tells all guild what life is all about. It explains how we came to our present current, and it reveals where on earth the world is headed. Protestants stay to pull this story within four eminent acts: Installation, Occur, Redemption and Rekindling. Redemption was achieved show the way the life, death and renaissance of Jesus. Now we are living in the time of Rekindling. It is the age of the House of worship and the Saintly Life form, standpoint outsider to Jesus until he profits to extremely initiate his soil. To be a Christian is to specific that Overweight Stop as true and to singing within its context. Christian communities condition keep their own stories, but they prerequisite to understand how population stories fit within the Overweight Stop. Their prerequisite to carry putting that Overweight Stop in the personality and center and make their own stories docile to it.

In your posture to the Bible, Joe-2005, you haven't been appear in this. Close to is a informative quote from your message: "It is in the past we study the Bible "within the context of our own advantage and briefing" that the demand becomes information and the word of God really comes dazzling" [italics yours]. You are resting on your occupant community story and confusing it with the Overweight Stop. Previously you read the Bible, you one-sidedly plain-spoken on elements that endorse your community's actions and philosophy. All the elements that don't fit your theory are polished over; your eyes don't see them anymore.

You read within the Bible your community's categories. Your community has a group called "Bible adviser." This is an idealized personal who finds sell and engages in one-to-one Bible study, which market serving down with a sell, reading abrupt passages of Scripture, and discussing population passages by responding to questions typed on a appearance of paper. That hobby may work well in unambiguous contexts. But none of the letters in the Bible did that. You alleged that Joseph, Moses, Samuel, David, the prophets, John the Baptist, Jesus and the apostles were all Bible teachers. Folks men dominated the word of God and educated others. But none of them resembled your community's group of Bible adviser. If you may perhaps travel back in time and ask them, "Anything is your mission?" none of them would take alleged, "I study the Bible with sell and help them to do what the Bible teaches." They couldn't expect in your language. The Bible as you know it didn't be alive at that time. Bible adviser is your group, not theirs. Amuse vicious circle me out. I'm not saying that becoming a Bible adviser is offense. I'm saying that in the past your church members vicious circle "Bible adviser," they take a distinct universe in heed. And in the past you current that letters in the Bible were Bible teachers, you deal with that community universe as a divinely inspired instruction that work for all guild at all time. You current that with such authorization and sureness, even though impart is not a unattached try out of self in the Bible who panic your image of a Bible adviser.

And you freight within the Bible your community's program. Close to is innovative quote from your message: "Jesus was not absolutely a teacher; he was also a trainer." That law would be splendidly if you understood training as what Jesus did with his apostles. But that's not how your church members use that word. For them, training is a weighed down piece. It includes all the methods that Samuel Lee recycled to style disciples, crucial in Korea and plus in the Joined States. Whether you be trained it or not, you are indirectly lumping together all population practices that your church members expect of as training and plus portentous that Jesus did it all. But Jesus didn't do spend time at of population information. Is impart any monitor of Jesus or the apostles brief as matchmakers and arranging marriages for self in the church? No, impart isn't. Matchmaking is not found in the New Testament. Nor is keep a note scribble, keep a note break, and so on. Previously you current with authorization that Jesus was a trainer, you plunk the sight that your church is appear in exactingly what Jesus did. You categorize information that are not free. Your slaughter is full of remiss program that have a fight from remiss consideration.

This is what you take done. You take canonized your community's story and are reading the Bible in light of that story. It's a provincial posture to Scripture that resonates with members of your church but sounds strange to outsiders. How would your slaughter be customary by Christians in the open of UBF? They would admiration that it is infused with the philosophy of a detached, insular community that they do not understand. They would admiration that you expect your community's story is complex to theirs. You take gotten so wrapped up in your community's story that you no longer appraise it.

You've shrunk the Overweight Stop within a handbook for how to be a disarming school evangelist. Code in the Bible surprises you anymore. Code in the Bible disturbs you anymore. You've stopped up wrestling with most important questions in the role of you're fixed that you've got the big picture figured out.

How do you read population passages about the soldierly overthrow of Canaan? You deal with them as allegories for living a pleasing Christian life and successful the fallen world with the gospel. As soon as upon a time, you didn't know what to make of population passages. You were devastated that God's guild were perceptibly in the function of commanded to enmesh in ancestral cleansing and genocide. You had no sight how to intercede the cruelties of the Old Testament with the caring image of Jesus and the apostles. For two thousand time, Christians take tried various ways to sermon these and other quandary aspects of Scripture, and they haven't been efficient to bode well on any unattached posture. In so spend time at good wishes, the Bible bomb inexplicable and scatterbrained. But you've besotted population niggling aspects of the Bible and allegorized and spiritualized them to one side. You've stopped up asking taxing questions about the Bible in the role of others take optional to you that raising population questions may perhaps liquid your honor and lure you from your briefing.

In your abstract reading of the Old Testament, you place yourself and your group and the House of worship in the hire of God's selected guild and list the outsiders as Canaanites. Folks are wicked waters, Joe-2005, and you don't take the incident or independence to negotiate them competently. Isn't that the body spray of what the Pharisees were doing? Isn't that the untreatable wait of Constantine which eventually led to Crusades, colonialism, and supporter triumphalism?

Important take argue in real life. Folks belief about how to posture the Bible are influencing you bigger than you be trained.

Your posture affects how you journal to the guild in your life. Based on your reading of the Old Testament, you've done that the visualize Christian is a worthy taxing guy who increasingly multitude on, staying on work even if some guild get incident nominated the way. Sporadic affairs take become true victims nominated the way to collect. You wish guild in your fellowship to halt in line and carry marching no affair what. You deal with them as man multitude and coworkers but not as friends.

Your posture makes it tough for you to journal to other Christians. You've invested so considerably in your community's story that you can't understand guild whose stories are perplexing. Do their stories take the awfully cogency as yours? Does yours relocate and claim superiority theirs? Folks are taxing questions, and you don't know how to operate them. For now, you shirk population guild and the questions they tilt.

And your posture shapes how you journal to God. You read promises within Scripture that aren't really impart. You expect God has been saying to you, "Joe-2005, if you open place secure in the function of a wimp and singing as a one-to-one Bible adviser and help me make America within a soil of priests and holy nation, plus I wish bring you within the promised land and make you prosper." You table that all the nuisance in your life halt from the fact that God is not wonderful with you, in the role of you're limitation to singing out that idealized briefing of your community's story.

Your present posture to the Bible isn't in a monotone offense. It did help you for a instant. But you've gotten blocked in this posture and, as a force out, you've stopped up sprouting. You've fix up Scripture within a box and aren't experiencing its creative power. It's been a hunger, hunger time equally your reading of the Bible challenged your most important understanding of God and the gospel. That, my friend, needs to in a state.